When Walking Away Just Gives Them What They Want

When Walking Away Just Gives Them What They Want

Dealing With Their Big Reaction Without Ending The Conversation

Welcome to Love Notes For Real Life! This is my space away from the noise of social media to dive deep into all the tricky, nuanced relationship topics you're struggling and puzzling over. Yes, it's a paid newsletter, but I promise it's worth it (and it's less than a fancy latte). You get weekly+ explorations, advice, and insight from me—a psychologist, high conflict couples therapist, and author. I hope you join the party!

Stick Around

Let's play out a situation. You bring up a tricky subject with your partner. You say your piece thoughtfully, without coming in hot or attacking them.

But unfortunately, they are experiencing a different version of this conversation, one that exists only in their own psyche. They start defending themselves. They poke at your logic. They take an adversarial approach to a dialogue that was supposed to get you on the same page.

You can ask them to cool their jets and actually hear you. But what if that doesn't work? What if they stay defensive and prickly?

Or...here's a different flavor. What if they shut down and get hopeless and disengaged? They don't jab at you, but they deactivate in front of your eyes. You can't have a productive conversation with someone who is metaphorically powering down.

The most obvious option in these situations is to let your partner know you can't engage in a conversation where there is reactivity or withdrawal. You say, "I'm available to talk when you can actually listen."

But here's the thing. That's just fine for them! Clearly, they did not want to have this conversation with you in the first place! So when you set your boundary around how you can engage, they're getting exactly what they want. And you're left out to dry in terms of talking through something that you need resolution or action around!

If you're reading this with your hand in the air shouting "me, me, me" at your phone, this one is written straight from me to you. Because I know. I know. The idea that your best option in this situation is to "set a boundary" and walk away is totally unacceptable. What does that solve?

And yet, sometimes that may feel like the only reasonable choice when your partner is activated or uncooperative. Even though walking away leaves you with your needs unmet.

I sat down to write this essay with one goal in mind: lay out some better options!

Because although I do know there's a place for limiting access to yourself when your partner can't show up with care and curiosity, that doesn't have to be your only move in this scenario. You are not wrong that walking away when the conversation gets tough will reinforce the negative pattern that is already happening...one where your attempts at dialogue are very effectively shut down by their defensive reaction.

So, let's get straight to it.

This post is for paying subscribers only

Already have an account? Sign in.